Why a Campaign’s Dollar Can Beat a Super PAC’s Dollar

One of the clearest patterns of the 2026 Senate elections ran against the biggest money. In six battleground states Democrats won (Iowa, Kansas, Maine, Michigan, Ohio and Texas), the candidate who raised more in direct contributions beat an opponent who often had substantially more outside support. “The more reliable predictor was candidate fundraising,” OpenSecrets concluded, according to The New Republic.

That can seem surprising in a year when super PACs spent record sums. But there are concrete reasons a dollar raised by a campaign often goes further than a dollar spent by a super PAC, along with real limits on what this pattern proves.

The fundraising gap

In the races where third-quarter reports were covered in detail, the winning Democrats far outraised their opponents in the final full quarter before the election:

RaceWinner raised (July–Sept.)Loser raised (July–Sept.)Result
TexasTalarico (D): $60.2MPaxton (R): $10.2MTalarico won
MaineJackson (D): $20.4MCollins (R): $5.2MJackson won
IowaTurek (D): $13.9MHinson (R): $3.3MTurek won
KansasHamilton (D): $9.9MMarshall (R): $0.9MHamilton won
South CarolinaAndrews (D): $9.4MGraham (R): $1.8M*Andrews won
Third-quarter FEC reports as reported by Roll Call and Iowa Public Radio (Oct. 16, 2026). *Graham entered the race on July 23. Ohio and Michigan, also in the OpenSecrets analysis, are not shown because comparable quarterly figures were not reported.

Outside money mostly ran the other way. In Texas, Texas PAC alone spent about $181.6 million backing Ken Paxton. In Ohio, the Senate Leadership Fund, No Going Back PAC and crypto super PACs put well over $100 million into the race for Jon Husted, who lost. Counting all outside groups on both sides, $424.5 million was spent on Ohio’s Senate race, nearly five times the $88.1 million the candidates themselves raised, according to OpenSecrets figures reported by cleveland.com. (In the final two weeks, outside spending was more evenly matched in several states; see Did the Money Work?)

Reason 1: Candidates get a discount on TV ads

Federal law requires TV and radio stations to sell ad time to candidates at the “lowest unit charge,” the lowest rate the station gives its best commercial customers for a comparable ad, during the 45 days before a primary and the 60 days before a general election. The discount applies only to candidates buying ads for their own campaigns. Super PACs and other outside groups get no such protection and pay whatever the market will bear.

In a crowded race, the difference can be large. In a 2022 Ohio Senate race, Politico found a Cleveland station charging MAGA Inc. $1,200 for a 30-second ad during a Sunday morning news show, while the Democratic candidate’s campaign paid $420 for the same slot. This year, Scripps News, using AdImpact data, found that Republicans, who relied far more on outside groups, paid about $274 per rating point in nine competitive Senate races in September, compared with about $201 for Democrats. In Texas, a Republican super PAC paid roughly $1,400 per airing of its top ad, while Talarico’s campaign paid roughly $500 per airing of its own.

The rules were also in flux this year. In March, the Federal Communications Commission said the discount also covers certain party and joint fundraising committees working with candidates. A federal appeals court struck that down in August, but the Supreme Court put the ruling on hold on Sept. 4, restoring the FCC’s guidance through the election. The case is expected to return to the Court. None of this extended the discount to super PACs.

Reason 2: Campaigns control their own message

Super PACs are legally barred from coordinating their spending with the candidates they support. That means they often guess at what message the campaign wants, sometimes repeating it, sometimes muddling it. A campaign decides its own message, timing and targeting, and can change course quickly. Late-forming super PACs also tend to buy airtime close to Election Day, when ad space is scarce and most expensive. A Senate Majority PAC spokesperson told Scripps that an ad booked in February costs far less than the same ad bought in September.

Reason 3: Fundraising is a signal of support

Candidates can accept only limited contributions from each donor, so raising tens of millions usually means a very large number of people chose to give. Those donors often volunteer, talk to neighbors and vote. A super PAC funded by a handful of billionaires shows that a few people care a great deal; it does not show broad enthusiasm. Some of the gap in the table above probably reflects voters’ mood as much as it causes the result.

What the pattern doesn’t prove

  • It’s a small sample in a wave year. Six races, all won by one party in a strong year for that party, cannot show whether fundraising caused the wins or simply tracked the same national mood.
  • Raising more did not always win. In Nebraska, independent Dan Osborn outraised Sen. Pete Ricketts in the third quarter, about $4.1 million to $2.2 million, and lost.
  • Cash on hand told a different story. Several losing Republicans, including Husted, Mike Rogers in Michigan and Ashley Hinson in Iowa, ended September with more money in the bank than their opponents, Roll Call reported. The winners raised more and spent it faster.
  • Outside money still matters. Super PACs can decide primaries, define little-known candidates and keep a race competitive. The 2026 results show that outside money has limits, not that it has no effect.

For how the biggest outside spenders fared, see our 2026 scorecard and The Billionaires Who Paid for the 2026 Midterms.

Sources

Published by SuperPACs.com. Figures come from Federal Election Commission filings and the sources listed above. Read about how we work and our editorial standards.